What Gets Measured Gets Improved
Running outreach without tracking metrics is like running a business without looking at revenue.
You might feel busy. But are you effective?
The Metrics That Matter
Open rate. Are people even seeing your emails? Below 30%? Your subject lines need work — or your emails are hitting spam. Our tips on writing headlines that get clicks apply to subject lines too.
Reply rate. 10-20% is good for cold outreach. Below 5%? Your messaging is off.
Positive reply rate. Not all replies are good ("please remove me from your list"). Track genuinely interested responses separately.
Link placement rate. Of the people who replied positively, how many actually placed a link? This measures your follow-through.
Cost per link. Total outreach costs (tools + time + content creation) divided by links placed. Critical for ROI analysis. Our guide on tracking link building ROI goes deeper.
Time to placement. How long from first email to live link? This helps you forecast results.
Benchmarks From 500+ Campaigns
If your numbers are below these, something in your system needs fixing. Ahrefs' link building guide offers additional benchmarks worth reviewing.
Track and Iterate
Review your metrics weekly. Test different subject lines, email body copy, follow-up cadences, and targeting criteria.
Small improvements compound fast. A 2% increase in reply rate across 1,000 emails is 20 more conversations.
Track outreach alongside your full SEO strategy at SEO Checkup. 113 tasks. Free.